Individual and Group Decision Making Under Risk: An Experimental Study of Bayesian Updating and Violations of First-order Stochastic Dominance
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper, we report the results of experiments designed to test whether individuals and groups abide by the axioms of monotonicity, with respect to first-order stochastic dominance and Bayesian updating, when making decisions in the face of risk. The results indicate a significant number of violations of both principles. The violation rate when groups make decisions is substantially lower, and decreasing with group size, than when solitary individuals make decisions, suggesting that social interaction or consultation improves the decision-making process. Greater transparency for the decision task tends to reduce the violation rate, suggesting that these violations are due to errors of judgment rather than reflecting the structure of the preference relations. However, we do find some cases where the less difficult decision leads to a higher rate of decision error, both for individuals and groups; we argue that this is consistent with the representativeness bias. We thank Nick Burger, Asen Ivanov, Jim Peck, Tim Salmon, and in particular John Kagel for valuable comments. Charness thanks the Department of Economics at UCSB for funding, Karni thanks the Department of Economics at Johns Hopkins University for funding, and Levin thanks the National Science Foundation for funding.
منابع مشابه
Electricity Procurement for Large Consumers with Second Order Stochastic Dominance Constraints
This paper presents a decision making approach for mid-term scheduling of large industrial consumers based on the recently introduced class of Stochastic Dominance (SD)- constrained stochastic programming. In this study, the electricity price in the pool as well as the rate of availability (unavailability) of the generating unit (forced outage rate) is considered as uncertain parameters. Th...
متن کاملDecision criteria in risk analysis : an application of stochastic dominance with respect to a function
متن کامل
Effect of Cognitive Biases on Rationality of Economic Decision Making under Risk among Students of Shahid Beheshti University
The purpose of this study is to determine the quality of individual economic decision making under risk and uncertainty. The research method is a quasi-experiment with single group and a post-test. The total population of the students of Shahid Beheshti University in 97 was 8.700 and due to non-normal distribution, we should use non-parametric Wilcoxon test, with sample of 180. The tool used to...
متن کاملModifying the Mean-Variance Approach to Avoid Violations of Stochastic Dominance
The mean-variance approach is an influential theory of decision under risk proposed by Markowitz (1952). Unfortunately, the mean-variance approach allows for violations of the first-order stochastic dominance. This paper proposes a new model in the spirit of the classical mean-variance approach but without violations of stochastic dominance. The proposed model represents preferences by a functi...
متن کاملAn economic-risk analysis of alternative rotations by stochastic simulation in Fars province
ABSTRACT - Cultivation of legumes in crop rotations results in atmosphere nitrogen fixation. After harvesting, part of this external nitrogen remains in soil and is used by subsequent crops. This implies that producers would gain from lowering the amount of nitrogen fertilizer in their fields. In this study, stochastic simulation is used to generate probability distributions of net present valu...
متن کامل